Prospects for Arab-Israeli Regional Cooperation
Vice Prime Minister Silvan Shalom

Jerusalem Issue Brief Vol. 9, No. 19 7 February 2010

. Regional cooperation begins with resuming negotiations with the
Palestinians. In the interests of achieving a just, lasting, and
comprehensive peace, Israel sees the economic domain as one of the
cornerstones of good relations.

?

. Political dialogue with our Palestinian partners is critical, but it will
not be furthered by allowing a settlement freeze to be imposed as a
precondition to negotiation. Nor will it be advanced by a unilateral
Palestinian declaration of statehood.

?

. Beyond the Palestinian question, the largest obstacle to regional peace is
the current Iranian regime, which continues to do everything in its power to
undermine the moderate regimes in the Middle East, the Israeli-Palestinian
peace process, and the good relations that Israel might have with Muslim and
Arab countries.

?

. If Syria is transferring missiles to Hizbullah, then Syria cannot be
serious about making peace. Although Syrian rhetoric is full of references
to that country's willingness to negotiate, Syrian support and financing of
terrorist organizations belie the claim. Still, Prime Minister Netanyahu has
stated clearly that he is willing to resume negotiations with Syria without
preconditions.

The Time Has Come to Make Peace

The time has come to make peace in the Middle East and, in my view, the
prospects are good, provided the Americans and the Europeans act judiciously
to help the parties involved narrow the gaps. 2

Regional cooperation begins with resuming negotiations with the
Palestinians. As Minister of Regional Cooperation, I am working to implement
some projects with the Arab world, but with the Palestinians it is more
difficult than with the others, in part because of the personalities
involved.

Prime Minister Salam Fayyad is trying to build his political career as an
independent. He is not part of Fatah, and many senior officials in Fatah
oppose him. They view him as someone who has spent too many years in the
United States and who had been "bought" by Condoleezza Rice and George Bush.
Fayyad knows that in order to build himself up as a political figure, he
must not engage Israel in a way that would hamper support from his
Palestinian constituency. The Palestinian Minister for National Economy,
Bassem Khoury, was forced to resign after he met with me under the auspices
of the Joint Economic Committee formed in 1995 in order to implement the
Paris Protocol, the economic part of the Oslo Accords.

Having met PA President Mahmoud Abbas and Salam Fayyad many times, I believe
that they are sincere about their willingness to move towards peace. Of
course they envision peace quite differently than Israel does. Abbas, for
instance, says that peace should include the implementation of the "right of
return," which of course would spell the end of the State of Israel.

Anyone who imagines that Marwan Barghouti, a terrorist currently serving
five life terms, should be president of the PA, or that he could bring an
end to the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, is gravely
mistaken.

Initiatives to Assist West Bank Development

In the meantime, there is much Israel can do to work toward the achievement
of a just, lasting, and comprehensive peace. First, Israel sees the economic
domain as one of the cornerstones of good relations. Some examples: Israel,
together with the EU (Germany, in particular), is trying to set up an
industrial zone in Bethlehem. Israel has opened a vehicle crossing that will
enable 500 cars a day to cross from the Israeli side to Jenin in the West
Bank. Israeli Arabs shopping in Nablus and other places are helping the PA
economy to grow at a rate of close to 8 percent.

The American Jewish Committee's Paris representative, Valérie Hoffenberg,
who also acts as a special envoy of President Nicolas Sarkozy, comes to
Israel every two weeks, and now she would like to get involved with the
project to link the Red Sea and Dead Sea with a canal. We are also planning
to develop the Jordan River for tourists, so that they can access the place
where, according to the New Testament, Jesus was baptized by St. John. We
are working to grant licenses to Jordanian investors to enable them to build
in the Ramallah area. Finally, to ease the daily life of the Palestinians,
Israel has removed hundreds of roadblocks and checkpoints since the
Netanyahu government came into power in April 2009. 3

The Need for Political Dialogue

Progress must come not only through economic measures, but also through
political dialogue. The settlement freeze initiated by Prime Minister
Netanyahu in order to restart negotiations with the Palestinians was
unprecedented. No settlement freeze was imposed on Prime Minister Ehud Barak
when he offered the Palestinians 90 percent of the territories, nor on Prime
Minister Ariel Sharon when he carried out the disengagement from Gaza, nor
on Prime Minister Ehud Olmert when he offered 96 to 98.5 percent of the West
Bank. Moreover, if negotiations begin with an agreement on the creation of a
Palestinian state and a settlement freeze - both issues for the final status
negotiations - then what is left to negotiate besides the status of
Jerusalem and the refugees, where there is a deadlock?

The recognition of Israel as a Jewish state is not a precondition. Israel's
recognition of the Palestinian right to an independent state is equivalent
to a Palestinian recognition of the existence of the State of Israel, which
by Israeli law is a Jewish state. It cannot be, therefore, that Israel will
recognize the Palestinian right to an independent state without Palestinian
recognition of Israel as a Jewish state. At the same time, the Palestinian
plan to unilaterally declare statehood in two years is not feasible; the
international community will not recognize a Palestinian state within the
1967 borders through Security Council fiat. A Palestinian state should be
achieved through dialogue and negotiations, and not as a unilateral move.

Israel will negotiate with Mahmoud Abbas and Salam Fayyad - or their
replacements if they resign - but not with Hamas, which has to this day not
abandoned its ambition to destroy Israel. According to the Hamas covenant,
the land currently occupied by Israel belongs not to the Palestinians, nor
to the Arabs, but to every Muslim around the world, which is why no Muslim -
whether he is a king or a president - has the right to relinquish even an
inch of that territory.

As foreign minister, I persuaded the European Union in 2004 to place Hamas
on the list of terrorist organizations, a decision that was followed
immediately by Canada, Australia, and Japan. Hamas still refuses to meet the
three conditions on negotiations agreed upon by the international community:
recognition of the existence of Israel, a renunciation of terrorism, and an
acceptance of previous agreements signed by the Palestinian Authority.

Israel desires peace, but a peace that will ensure security. If the
Palestinians come to the table, Israel will negotiate immediately.

The Iranian Threat

Beyond the Palestinian question, however, there are larger obstacles to
regional peace. The current Iranian regime - eager to revive the Persian
Empire and to become a regional power - continues to do everything in its
power to undermine the moderate regimes in the Middle East, 4

the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, and the good relations that Israel
might have with Muslim and Arab countries.

Regarding Iran's nuclear ambitions, the time has come to make decisions and
take action.

The dithering of the international community, which continues to beg the
Iranians to accept its offers, has merely enabled the Iranians to buy time.
The world no longer believes that a nuclear Iran is Israel's problem alone,
and indeed this may boost President Obama's efforts to reach a consensus for
tough sanctions. It is also true that Iran's high-volume trade with the
United States, the European Union, Canada, Australia, Japan, and others
makes it vulnerable to such sanctions. But Iran will never abandon its
ambitions to obtain nuclear weapons. To wait for a Security Council
resolution, therefore, is a waste of time. Russia and China, for one thing,
are not likely to impose real sanctions. Energy-hungry China has signed a
$75 billion oil contract with Iran.

Yet quite apart from its nuclear ambitions, Iran seeks to exert pressure on
regimes within the Middle East, and eventually to control the whole region.
A newly reinvigorated Hizbullah remains the long arm of Iran. Hizbullah is
now estimated to have 40,000 to 50,000 missiles with a much longer range
than it deployed during the Second Lebanon War in 2006. Hizbullah leader
Hassan Nasrallah recently claimed that his militia has missiles that put all
of Israeli territory within range. IDF Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi
admitted that Hizbullah now has missiles with a range of 300 kilometers, or
200 miles. Weapons smuggling from Iran and Syria to Lebanon continues
through Syria's Damascus airport and Latakia seaport in blatant violation of
UN Resolution 1701. UNIFIL is doing little, if anything, to stem the flow of
weapons.

Syrian Support for Terror Groups

Needless to say, if Syria is transferring missiles to Hizbullah, then Syria
cannot be serious about making peace. Although Syrian rhetoric is full of
references to that country's willingness to negotiate, Syrian support and
financing of terrorist organizations belie the claim. All the weapons sent
from Iran to Hizbullah go through Syria. Hamas and Islamic Jihad have
headquarters and training camps in Syria. Still, Prime Minister Netanyahu
has stated clearly that he is willing to resume negotiations with Syria
without preconditions.

Conclusion

We have in some respects already narrowed the gaps between Israel and
individual Arab countries. Egypt and Jordan have embassies in Israel, and
Israel has a significant natural gas agreement with Egypt. I have met the
foreign ministers of Pakistan and Indonesia and others from the Gulf States
and North Africa. I visited Tunisia - the first visit of an Israeli minister
to arrive in an Israeli airplane - as well as Turkey, Mauritania, and other
countries that cannot yet be revealed. Despite the region's many dangers, I
hope that through judicious negotiations, 5 responsible leadership, and deft
diplomacy, Israel can in the coming years do even more to foster regional
cooperation.

* * *

Silvan Shalom has served as Vice Prime Minister, Foreign Minister, Minister
of Finance, Minister of Science, and Deputy Minister of Defense. He is
currently Israel's Vice Prime Minister, Minister for Regional Development,
and Minister of Development of the Negev and Galilee. This Jerusalem Issue
Brief is based on his presentation to the Institute for Contemporary Affairs
in Jerusalem on November 12, 2009.

This Jerusalem Issue Brief is available online at:

http://www.jcpa.org

Dore Gold, Publisher; Yaacov Amidror, ICA Chairman; Dan Diker, ICA Director;
Mark Ami-El, Managing Editor. Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs
(Registered Amuta), 13 Tel-Hai St., Jerusalem, Israel; Tel. 972-2-561-9281,
Fax. 972-2-561-9112, Email: jcpa@netvision.net.il. In U.S.A.: Center for
Jewish Community Studies, 5800 Park Heights Ave., Baltimore, MD 21215; Tel.
410-664-5222; Fax 410-664-1228. Website: www.jcpa.org. © Copyright. The
opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of the Board of
Fellows of the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.

The Institute for Contemporary Affairs (ICA) is dedicated

to providing a forum for Israeli policy discussion and debate.

To subscribe to the Jerusalem Issue Brief list, please go to link:

http://www.list-jcpa.org/brief-sub.html

To unsubscribe from the Jerusalem Issue Brief list, go to link:

http://www.list-jcpa.org/mail-brief/forms/optoutform.asp