Palestinian Media Watch Bulletin
December 2, 2003

PALESTINIAN MEDIA WATCH
phone: 972- 2- 625-4140 fax: 972-2- 624-2803
visit our website, click here: http://www.pmw.org.il
for further information, contact PMW Director, Itamar Marcus
material may be quoted, citing PMW as the source
subscribe free to PMW reports, details below

PA celebrates "Geneva Agreement" while rejecting their only concession
by Itamar Marcus

Introduction:

The Palestinian Authority has been publicly praising the Geneva Agreement
signed yesterday between its representatives and representatives of the
Israeli extreme left, while sending clear statements of rejection to its
people regarding the one clause that obligates the Palestinians. On the
positive side the Palestinian Authority sees the Geneva Agreement as major
achievement, as prominent Israelis have agreed to 100% of the Palestinian
territorial demands. These Israeli concessions are all clear and explicitly
worded. A clear map is included with the agreement.

On the rejection side, the only Palestinian concession, that they give up
their demand to have "refugees" settle in Israel, was worded ambiguously.
While the agreement validates UN resolution 194, seen by the Palestinians as
giving them "right" to settle in Israel, the final number to settle is left
to Israel to determine, taking numerous undefined numbers into account.

This clear delineation of Israel's concessions juxtaposed against the
ambiguity of the Palestinian concession has enabled the Palestinian
Authority to truly celebrate: Israel is obligated; they are not.

This dual message has been explicitly stated repeatedly to the PA
population. Today's PA daily had no problem hailing the agreement and at the
same time expressing total rejection of the Israeli interpretation regarding
refugees. The paper included two full pages of reports on all the
Palestinian demonstrations against the agreement's clause to limit "the
right of return" and included three explicit statements by PA leaders of
rejection of relinquishing the "refugees rights."

The following statements are all from today's official daily, Al Hayat
Al-Jadida:

"The Minister of Foreign Affaires, Dr. Nebil Shaath, emphasized that the
Palestinians will never give up the right to return to their houses, and
will negotiate only about the procedures of returning. " [Dec. 2 2003,
Al-Hayat Al-Jadida]

"The Chairman of the Palestinian Legislative Council, Rafiq Al-Natshah,
emphasized that the Palestinian problem started with the refugees and will
not be solved unless the refugees return to their homes. He mentioned that
the sacrifices and the struggle of our people will not allow anyone to
forsake nor to concede any of our people's rights. He added: Anyone who
imagines that our people want peace at the expense of its rights, is wrong
and if the peace initiatives come at the expense of the right of our people,
let all the peace initiatives go to hell."[Al Hayat Al-Jadida] Dec. 2,
2003]

"The President [Arafat] blesses the conference of peace forces in Geneva"
and them immediately followed with: ".adhering to the legitimate
international decisions which include: [UN decision] 194." [Al Hayat
Al-Jadida] Dec. 2, 2003]

In summary, the Palestinian interpretation of the Geneva Agreement is that
Israel is obligated to hand over all the land and the refugee issue has to
still be decided.

This is why the Palestinians are celebrating.

to SUBSCRIBE to PMW's reports send an empty e-mail to
reports-subscribe@pmw.org.il