Shock, awe and dread
By Avi Issacharoff Haaretz 22 June 2007
Quiet returned to the streets of Gaza all at once this week - a quiet that
the Strip's residents had not experienced for more than two decades, since
the first intifada began. Within a few days, after its clashes with Fatah
ended in a decisive victory for Hamas, the Islamic movement managed to do
the incredible: It ended the chaos in Gaza. The descriptions provided by
residents and local and foreign journalists sound almost inconceivable: The
gunmen (not members of Hamas) have disappeared from the streets, apparently
due to a fear of the Hamas Executive Force.
And now that the movement has banned people from masking their faces, that
phenomenon has also ceased to exist. Members of the Public Order - a new
force established by Hamas to deal with urgent civil matters - now stand
guard at intersections. They are dressed in civilian clothes, identifiable
only by the word "Hamas" emblazoned on the backs of their yellow shirts.
Their primary task: maintaining the flow of traffic. They're basically Hamas
traffic cops, but they're backed up by the armed Executive Force, with whom
no one dares to argue. Force members also examine vehicle in the streets and
confiscate those suspected of being stolen.
At the same time, Iz a-Din al-Kassam, the Hamas military wing, is constantly
searching the homes of suspects. They collect the weapons of members of the
Palestinian security services and respond to the actions of the armed clans.
They have also promised a resolution to the abduction of BBC journalist Alan
Johnston. The Durmush clan, which is holding Johnston, is the last bastion
of opposition to Hamas in Gaza.
The Public Order force, meanwhile, spent part of this week supervising the
matriculation exams in Gaza schools, and it has prohibited merchants from
raising prices indiscriminately, according to F., who used to serve as a
senior officer in a Fatah security force. Though not a Hamas sympathizer, F.
says Gaza has become much safer for its residents since the movement's
takeover. "I haven't felt this secure in many years," he says. "The
situation here is even better than excellent from the security perspective.
For years, I used to smoke a hookah in cafes. Over the last few months,
though, I didn't dare leave the house after dark. Now I can go out again,
even at 2 A.M."
But there is, of course, a caveat. "The problem is that our economic future
looks bleak," F. continues. "It's not clear where we're going or how the
strip will look. Will Israel leave the border crossings closed or open them?
If the blockade continues, people will die here from the food shortage."
Hysteria has dissipated
Even those who were trying to get out of Gaza last week have relaxed a bit
since then. "I'm still pessimistic, but the hysteria has disappeared," says
A., a Palestinian man in his 40s. "I thought there wouldn't be any water or
electricity, and now, it's not that the situation is great, but everything
is continuing to function."
Like Gaza's residents, Hamas too is worried by the possibility that Israel
will close the border crossings. But when Israeli and international human
rights groups started worrying this week over the possibility that food
supplies in Gaza could run out within a month, Hamas realized that the
Israeli government would not be able to sit back and allow for the
starvation of more than 1.3 million Palestinians. Surprisingly, Hamas also
agreed to let private Palestinian groups maintain all the existing
arrangements at the crossings; the groups will operate in accordance with
security rules set by Israel. But all this doesn't mean that Hamas has given
up fighting Israel.
"Hamas will act against Israel, inevitably," predicts Salah Bardawil, one of
the movement's leaders in Gaza. "If you continue to oppress us economically
or security-wise, it will only result in a reaction on our part, and no one
will benefit from that. Our goal is to stabilize the internal situation in
the Strip and to resolve the residents' troubles. We also do not oppose
Israel's decision to allow the passage of [some Gaza] residents to the West
Bank. We won't hold anyone here by force."
If the improved security situation described by Gaza residents is
maintained, Israel is likely to encounter a problem that is opposite to the
one it faced at the Erez crossing on the Gaza-Israel border this week: West
Bank residents will start trying to go to Gaza. In the meantime, Fatah isn't
worried about its ability to cope with Hamas in the West Bank, and
Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas rushed this week to rule out
any negotiations with the other side. But if Israel opens the Gaza border
crossings, West Bank residents who witness increasing internecine violence
are liable to get jealous of their Palestinian brothers in Gaza who are
living under Hamas rule.
For now, at least, Fatah has not altered its behavior. Even the serious blow
it sustained in its clashes with Hamas in Gaza, and its concern for the
future of the West Bank, have not managed to suppress the internal
backstabbing in Fatah. This week most of its leaders in the West Bank were
more concerned with how to depose Mohammed Dahlan than how to defeat Hamas.
Even Dahlan's supporters from Gaza who came over to Ramallah preferred to
vilify their critics in Fatah (including Jibril Rajoub and Marwan Barghouti)
rather than to examine the mistakes they had made.
The near-perfect public order that reigned in Gaza this week can be
attributed, at least in part, to the fear Hamas struck into residents'
hearts last week, during the Strip's civil war. Testimony collected from the
days of fighting indicates that Hamas imposed a methodical system of terror
and scare tactics intended to deter, shock and frighten Fatah operatives and
Gaza residents in general.
It began on a Monday 11 days ago, when a Fatah man was tossed off a
multi-story building in the Strip; it subsequently came to light that Hamas
operatives managed to shoot him in the legs before throwing him to his
death. Although this method was used on only one other Fatah operative, it
had the desired effect and became the talk of the town. A number of Fatah
leaders, who knew that their names appeared on Hamas hit lists, decided to
make their exit, with some heading to Ramallah and others crossing into
"It's very easy to criticize the senior officials who disappeared," says a
Gazan journalist. "But you have to remember that they wanted to stay alive.
People had already tried to assassinate them in the past and they knew that
Hamas wanted their heads. Someone like that wants to survive."
Hamas was not using a random hit list. Every Hamas patrol carried with it a
laptop containing a list of Fatah operatives in Gaza, and an identity number
and a star appeared next to each name. A red star meant the operative was to
be executed and a blue one meant he was to be shot in the legs - a special,
cruel tactic developed by Hamas, in which the shot is fired from the back of
the knee so that the kneecap is shattered when the bullet exits the other
side. A black star signaled arrest, and no star meant that the Fatah member
was to be beaten and released. Hamas patrols took the list with them to
hospitals, where they searched for wounded Fatah officials, some of whom
they beat up and some of whom they abducted.
Aside from assassinating Fatah officials, Hamas also killed innocent
Palestinians, with the intention of deterring the large clans from
confronting the organization. Thus it was that 10 days ago, after an
hours-long gun battle that ended with Hamas overpowering the Bakr clan from
the Shati refugee camp - known as a large, well-armed and dangerous family
that supports Fatah - the Hamas military wing removed all the family members
from their compound and lined them up against a wall. Militants selected a
14-year-old girl, two women aged 19 and 75, and two elderly men, and shot
them to death in cold blood to send a message to all the armed clans of